
Adventureland is the latest release from director Greg Mottola, following protagonist James Brennan (Jesse Eisenberg) as he works his mundane summer job at a fairground. Most people should be familiar with Mr. Mottola - he directed 2007's famous / infamous comedy Superbad. Many will be quick to draw comparisons between these two films, but in truth, Adventureland's tone leans more towards Judd Apatow's brilliant 1999 series Freaks and Geeks. In some ways this betters the film, but in others, it lets it down.
This is in part due to the personality of the characters and their actions. While Superbad seemed to focus on stereotypes like the sex, party and drink-obsessed teens, the awkward geeks, the not-so-bright policemen, etc., etc., Adventureland's characters are much more human in their portrayal. The story's key concern here is main character James's affections for co-worker Em (played by Kristen Stewart of Twilight fame), and how this relationship plays out (as in my other reviews, I don't want to say much at all about what actually happens so you can experience it for yourself). All of the characters involved have likeable traits, but realistic flaws to go along with them, and this aids how much we can empathise with the people on-screen - there's more emotional investment here than there is in Superbad (I'm not saying that I didn't like Michael Cera, Jonah Hill and company, far from it; it's just that it's easier to sympathise with someone like James Brennan (in Adventureland), who is going through some "relationship issues," than it is with Seth in Superbad, who draws hilariously-detailed penises all over his school work). The relationships, like that between James and Em, are played out in a more pessimistic fashion - human flaws provide great obstacles for them, and the cast aren't concerned solely with sex.
While this certainly works partly in the film's favour, it's at the expense of its "enjoyment" factor. Superbad is mostly a comedy through-and-through, yet this film takes itself a lot more seriously. The character development that's present is good, but while something like Freaks and Geeks had many episodes in which to build personalities, Adventureland is a bit over 2 hours long, and so the extra time spent creating better characters means there is less time for comedy, which is a great shame.
There are some characters who are clearly exaggerated, albeit not completely out of the realm of possibility. Bobby the theme park manager (Bill Hader - Knocked Up, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, Superbad; you know, he's in most of the films that have anything to do with Judd Apatow), his partner Paulette (Kristen Wiig) and James's childhood friend Tommy Frigo (Matt Bush) all come to mind when I say that. The scenes they occupy are generally hilarious, particularly Bobby's (he's absolutely insane) - the majority of his scenes caused roars of laughter from us watching. It's these side characters that provide the majority of laughs, among others. But these characters are just reduced to the sidelines, as the plot mainly focuses on more serious ones like James, Em, and Connell (Ryan Reynold). While it's good that the storyline is more serious than Superbad, it's annoying that there isn't enough humour in it, when the humour that is there is so good.
The atmosphere and setting everything takes place in are spot-on however - it's set in the 1980s like Freaks and Geeks, and everything looks completely genuine for that era. The soundtrack is fitting for the period also, featuring songs by Judas Priest, Lou Reed, and David Bowie, among others. It all adds up to create what's most likely a genuine feeling of 1987. It's sometimes just fun to look around at the general aesthetic of the theme park, the rides, and such.
A few parts of the film drag, such as where there are long, lingering shots of characters kissing, which are repeated several times throughout. I can't help but feel these sorts of unnecessary "meaningful" seconds could've been replaced with funnier...seconds. While it's good that Mottola opted for a more serious venture this time around, he could've afforded to put in some more comedy to break it up a bit - sure, we care about the characters, and what happens to them, but it would've been better if we had more fun along the way. Still worth watching though; the main storyline is sincere, most of the characters are great (particularly the co-stars), the period is portrayed well, and the laughs that are there are make it an uplifting watch.
7.5/10



